Sovereignty and justice

← All topics
Casa de la Vall, the historic seat of the Consell General, with the mountains behind

The CJEU and EU law

Rulings of the EU Court of Justice (CJEU) become binding on Andorra (art. 96): EU law will be interpreted uniformly, above Andorran discretion.

EU acts incorporated into the Agreement must be interpreted and applied in line with CJEU case law, both before and after signature (art. 85.2).

The Agreement is not a bespoke regime: annexes I–XXV incorporate an extensive list of EU Directives, Regulations and Decisions that will apply in Andorra.

Traffic offences

Annex XIII (Transport), point 48, incorporates without adaptation Directive (EU) 2015/413 on the exchange of vehicle data to investigate road-safety traffic offences. The country where the offence is detected may look up, from the full registration number, the vehicle data and the name and address of the holder, and of the owner where the register has one. The directive, as the annex lists it, covers eight offences: speeding, not wearing a seat belt, running a red light, drink-driving, drug-driving, not wearing a helmet, using a forbidden lane, and illegally using a mobile phone while driving.

The search does not identify the driver. The country of the offence decides whether to open a case and send notice, under its own law. Collection of the fine lies outside this directive. Framework Protocol 1 extends to Andorra the duties Member States owe one another, and the exchange runs in both directions. The Council text (ST 11787/24 ADD 7) and the pre-Council draft match on this point.

Ratification and provisional application

Article 65 of the Constitution requires a two-thirds majority of the General Council to ratify treaties that transfer legislative, executive or judicial powers: the Agreement transfers all three.

Article 112.2 allows the Agreement to be applied provisionally, in whole or in part, until ratification, conclusion or approval is complete: from the month after a party deposits its instrument, unless another party notifies that provisional application cannot take place. Article 112.3 opens the same path between the EU and only one of the two states. That can bring application forward before a referendum. Current treaty law does not allow it, but that law can be amended by ordinary majority and open this path without a two-thirds vote in the General Council.

Provisional application would already replace the 1990 Customs Agreement: the Andorra Protocol (Art. 4) states the new customs union "replaces and succeeds" it, and Framework Protocol 2 does not list it among the agreements that survive. Nothing guarantees it would revive if ratification ultimately failed.

The negotiation

Critics argue the EU dictated the timelines and terms, leaving Andorra little room to negotiate.